Traditional vs. Instagram customer support: Which is better?

November 14, 2025

7 min.

While many traditional channels are providing excellent results, today we want to compare them with social media, especially Instagram customer support, which has stood out thanks to its market evolution and its dynamic communication. What we are really interested in is reconsidering whether this app could replace traditional customer service channels.

In this article, we will debate which of these two media may be best for your customer support. We may even find that both can coexist without problems and offer a complete service. Let’s find out!

Create an account in Kommo

Note: Two distinct concepts you’ll find are social media marketing and traditional marketing. According to Landingi, it’s essential to identify the differences between the two so that you can create a seamless and optimized service.

Key features and advantages of Instagram customer support

Customer service on Instagram is characterized by sending dynamic and fun messages through various media. You can interact with people in different ways and provide interesting promotions and posts through images, videos, or stories. Let’s see the features and advantages of it:

Working with Instagram’s features (direct messages, stories, etc.)

Instagram has its own specific features for serving and interacting with customers. The best part is that you can use several strategies to capture your customers’ attention with every contact. Therefore, you can choose to work with any or all of these to create exceptional service.

Improve efficiency and speed

The reality is that working through automated support available in a recognized application becomes an excellent advantage in terms of efficiency and speed. Your customers won’t need to wait for a response or delay in managing their sales or requesting services.

Increase satisfaction from a single channel

Managing through Instagram makes brands and customers feel great satisfaction. We’re talking about a dynamic and entertaining platform that allows you to get to know your brand visually and textually. Additionally, you can carry out all procedures and registrations through a single platform.

Understanding Instagram customer support

We know that Instagram is an app dedicated to engaging with people through various multimedia approaches (photos, videos, comments, etc.). Beyond knowing what it’s about, it’s also important to understand how Instagram customer support works for businesses:

Real-time interactions through DMs and comments

Instagram has an excellent way to engage reliably with its customers: automated interactions through Instagram DM and comments. With this, you can:

  • Provide personalized and reliable support.
  • Interact immediately and personally when they respond to a story.
  • Verify preferences and suggestions through comments.
  • Quickly and directly identify who is interested in your company.

Note: Kommo is an optimal CRM that allows you to automatically and seamlessly create and manage comments and DMs processed on your Instagram account. Ultimately, it can benefit your customer service.

Case studies of brands using Instagram effectively

Currently, there are popular brands that choose Instagram to carry out their campaigns. Among these are Airbnb, which, thanks to this platform, sells exceptional travel experiences instead of rooms, and Nike, which uses Instagram to motivate and inspire its consumers, encouraging them to use its products for a more active life.

Thus, Instagram customer support, more than just a messaging channel, is a channel where you can share experiences and drive business growth through valuable posts.

Traditional support channels explained

Let's now talk about and explain the channels that have always been our go-to for customer service—traditional support channels:

1. Phone support and call centers

Call centers have been used for years (and are still in use) to capture user interest and thus drive sales. They even provide immediate customer service to address various situations such as complaints, guides, or even emergencies. This is a service that is unlikely to go out of style, as it offers enormous benefits to the various industries that require it.

2. Email-based support systems

Email is a classic means of customer service for businesses. They can send publications, news, or formal promotions with a higher level of development and professionalism. Among many others, it is the preferred medium for increasing customer production and interest.

Note: While many modern customers prefer quick responses via direct message, others still turn to more traditional options, such as an Instagram customer support email, which offers a formal record of communication and is the most convenient for complex issues.

3. Live chat and helpdesk ticketing

Although artificial intelligence is gaining ground, it’s true that many customers require immediate assistance via live chat, which constantly increases their interest and attention towards the company.

On the other hand, another classic channel that remains important is help desk ticket management, which processes customer requests to organize, track, and resolve complex issues that require collaboration between multiple teams.

Get a demo

Traditional vs. Instagram customer support: A Direct Comparison

Now that we’ve learned about each method separately, let’s do a direct comparison between Instagram customer support and traditional support for your business assistance:

1. Speed and response time

When it comes to speed of results, Instagram customer support automation takes the lead. While traditional support provides empathetic and personalized responses, the difference in response time is considerable compared to an intelligent tool.

2. Personalization and customer experience

When it comes to personalization and customer experience, both can deliver great results. The difference will depend on the number of customers you are willing to serve. Traditional support is responsible for providing completely personalized service to a specific number of customers, while Instagram customer support has the capacity to provide massive service.

Note: Personalized service varies depending on the tool you use. This will depend on the specific features of each platform. For example, email support provides classic, personalized support tailored to the interests of a specific group of customers, while Instagram manages dynamic, unique messages for the target audience.

3. Scalability and automation

In terms of scalability and automation, Instagram will provide better results. This doesn’t mean that traditional support offers poor results; on the contrary, it just means that its capabilities are limited in these areas. It’s important to keep in mind that Instagram can integrate with other tools (such as chatbots or artificial intelligence), thereby providing more growth opportunities.

4. Cost-effectiveness for businesses

The issue of profitability will depend on your capabilities. That is, if you’re a large company that’s not concerned about the financial aspect, choosing traditional support with human agents won’t be detrimental. However, if you’re a small business and need excellent results without investing too much, Instagram customer support is the best option.

Request partner help in Kommo

Challenges of Instagram customer support

Although we’ve stated that Instagram customer support is the best thing your customer service can do, it certainly presents certain challenges that must be overcome to create the ideal service:

1. Managing high message volumes

Managing a high volume of customers is a success; however, it also brings certain challenges, especially when it comes to maintaining the quality of the response and the agility of sending interactions. Therefore, it’s important to pay attention to these elements to create a great Instagram customer support contact.

2. Training teams for social-first communication

To create exceptional service, we must ask ourselves how to contact Instagram customer support. The best way is to manage team training to create social media-centric communication. The challenge that may be embedded in this case is not maintaining a clear structure for managing authentic communication, so you must provide them with the necessary help and support at all times.

3. Privacy and compliance concernsv

Instagram has its own privacy policy and rules that must be followed. If, for any reason, these are ignored or if any clause (even a minor one) is ignored, there is a risk of your account being blocked or terminated. These types of platforms are excellent, but they must be handled with caution to provide reliable service.

When to use Traditional vs. Instagram customer support

Asking you to choose just one tool seems inhumane. Ideally, you should be able to take advantage of what both offer and thus create successful customer service. That said, here’s how to use traditional customer service and customer support on Instagram:

Best scenarios for Instagram customer support

In many cases, you’ll need agile responses, especially for impatient customers eager to request your products and services; in this case, Instagram is an excellent option. Additionally, you can create a sales funnel that encourages consumption through interactive stories or sweepstakes.

Situations where traditional support excels

When delicate situations arise, digital support isn’t always convenient (it can generate mistrust and frustration). This is where traditional channels, such as phone calls or traditional support like emails, take center stage. Customers will quickly find a live agent who can provide greater empathy and secure solutions.

Combining both for an omnichannel strategy

Omnichannel support is also a possibility. You can combine both forms of support, with Instagram focusing on increasing your production and sales levels, while traditional support handles complex situations that require human agents.

Subscribe to the Kommo YouTube channel

Conclusion: Finding the right balance

While we can conclude that Instagram customer support is the most efficient and dynamic tool for engaging in conversations, the reality is that the best strategy would be to find a balance between it and traditional support. One way to do this is by evaluating our own business and determining the service we want to provide. After that, we should address all the characteristics, challenges, and strategies we discussed, and then steer the service in the direction we want.

The assistance of human agents will always be necessary; we cannot deny this. Therefore, it’s best to let automation handle repetitive tasks and frequent messages, while representatives are responsible for providing personalized support through traditional channels. Now, to build this ideal balance, it’s best to work your Instagram customer support with efficient software like Kommo, an excellent conversational CRM that will deliver the right kind of success for your business.

Contact us for a chat or a free demo session.

💬 Chat with us here on the website or within your account

🤓 Book a free demo session with the team

🤝 Find a partner to do it for you so that you can relax

🎥 Visit our YouTube Channel

Carmen Figuera

Content Writer in Kommo. A literature lover who keeps her feet on the ground while her hands dive into a good book. With my imagination soaring, I create amazing content for Kommo!

Try Kommo free

Test drive Kommo yourself or schedule a free demo call with us